Tuesday, April 10, 2018

Kevin D. Williamson: Laverne Cox: Also Not A Woman

Again, he's right on target:
As a matter of government, I have little or no desire to police how Cox or any other man or woman conducts his or her personal life. But having a culture organized around the elevation of unreality over reality in the service of Eros, who is a sometimes savage god, is not only irrational but antirational. Cox’s situation gave him an intensely unhappy childhood and led to an eventual suicide attempt, and his story demands our sympathy; times being what they are, we might even offer our indulgence. But neither of those should be allowed to overwhelm the facts, which are not subject to our feelings, however sincere or well intended.
As I've always said: Cox and people like him should be able to live and look however they damn well please. But it's impossible, at our current level of technology, to change your sex. (And, as a sidebar: it's insane to mutilate your junk given that you'll end up, at best, with a quasi-functional simulacrum of the opposite kind.) And any attempt to make the rest of us pretend that hes are shes and vice-versa is a psychotic slice of totalitarianism.

2 Comments:

Anonymous RG said...

Bracket what this article is actually about. I got hung up on the very first line, which almost acts as a subheadline: "Facts are not subject to our feelings." Hmm, is that true? I suppose I'm also just curious about your own philosophical commitments. So what says the Philosoraptor? "Facts are not subject to our feelings." Toe claws up or down?

9:06 AM  
Blogger Winston Smith said...

Yeah, I know what he means...and it didn't register with me when I read it...but you're right, he's wrong. I mean...feelings are real states, and real states have effects on other real states. There's no doubt that feelings (which participate in facts themselves) can affect other facts. They get people killed sometimes, for one thing.

It's a good point. I guess what he means is: feelings (of the relevant kinds) can't have the kinds of effects that the left seems to think they can have. If a man feels like a woman, that can have all sorts of real consequences...but it can't have the specific kind of consequence that trans gender ideology attributes to it. Most notably: making him a woman.

Good eye, RG. I'm chagrined by how many times claims like that have slipped right by me.

9:12 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home